Two last points,
Scotty DID take the perspective of space moving. Just old Scotty, not young Scotty. It was Mr Scott's equation that old Spock was using, and passing on to young Scott. Experience, it makes a difference.
And two, I almost cried in the begining of that movie. the death scene. So many death scenes have been wasted in Startrek. So many make me feel nothing if not left down. If he can bring that kind of sadness to Fumio's death, I'd be a happy man. Hell, Murikami's, or anyones! Spock and Kirk and fought before, but to give Spock the weakness of his mother, and to fight over that, imagine what perspective he would take when Sho decides to protect Mitsuki.
One of my favorite episodes of the 2005 series was near the end, when the humans were in hiding while Chronos ruled the world. You could see that everyone in the house was developing cabin fever. To see Shizu slowly knitting her sweater, then finally lose it in the end was great drama. I love seeing that kind of drama. That is why I will defend Abrams. There is a CHANCE that he could do it justice. On the other hand, he could screw it up completely. Either way
Now who wants to talk about what Ewe Boll would do to it? A man that couldn't care about the quality of the movie for nothing